It was very nice
The things that stood out to me was that this movie seems less like a aq2 movie than the rest of them... It felt more like a "real" action movie than about a game, the intro was simply brilliant.
I for one loved the music, and thought it was well suited for the movie. Many of these songs could be found on a real action movie soundtrack as well.
The editing and effects were simply brilliant, and I loved that fly through session on riot where the viewer is taken from action bits to action bits by cameraruns through the map. Brilliant I tell you
The only real minus with this movie (and this is why I still think that it loses to AU2) is the frags. There were some spectacular ones, but overall they felt pretty "regular".
Overall I'd say that this would be a 9/10 in my book. Great work man!