Ralle wrote:The problem as i see it is that some of the Quake 2 clients give some powerfull commands that in some situations will be an advantage when playing. Most people allready know the cl_coloredlightmaps command which is a 'light' version of the feature in Q2PRO where the map becomes totally greyed out. One could also argue that the cl_coloredlightmaps command is also to some extent cheat since you can also grey colors out on a map which will in return make the enemy easier to spot.
The question is wheter an advantage gained through a perfectly valid command in our quake 2 clients is to be considered cheats or not, and if so what to do about it. A cl_maxfps value of 100 is also possible within the clients themselves, but it is the servers that restricts this setting to 3 or 5, since a value over this is also considered an unfair advantage on certain maps. Q2PRO has a command that will basically make your map fullbright (not mentioning it here), giving the Q2PRO user a advantage (bigger than this grey feature if u ask me), which other clients are restricted by through cl_maxfps limit of 3.
Maybe the serveradmins should consider making restrictions to certain of the new commands, unless they are of the opinion that what is possible with an quake 2 client is never regarded a cheat or unfair advantage.
Good, informative post all in all. N1 Ralle.
I agree with you regarding the admins, though it'll sadly never see the light of day. Most of those that can make a difference wont and the few that do gets ignored, flamed or worse.
About the setting cl_coloredlightmaps I can safely say I know jack shit about. GL_coloredlightmaps on the other hand is in APRQ2 since 1.20 or even earlier and I've been using that command for the past 3 years or so. Makes it easier on my old eyes is all. If by some legislation in the supreme court of United Admins of Quake2 it'd be deemed a cheat I'd gladly remove it. No big deal really.
But to get back to the first post...
jambalaya uses a setting/tweak/command that's in most, if not all used clients these days which means anyone can do it.
Admins react if you feel it's necessary.
To me it still don't feel like a cheat, setting or not. If you can't see a big-assed male all painted in
red,
blue,
yellow or
green... I mean, come the fuck ON?!